2016 – Alyssa Taglia

2015 – Colleen Ward

2014 – Acacia Courtney

2013 – Kaitlyn Tarpey

2012 – Emily Audibert

2011 – Morgan Amarone

2010 – Brittany Decker

2009 – Sharalynn Kuziak

2008 – Ashley Glenn

2007 – Dana Daunis

2006 – Heidi Voight

2005 – Dianna Baitinger

2004 – Nicki Palmieri

2003 – Marla Prete

2002 – Tanisha Brito

 

2001 – Marissa Perez Cardona

2000 – Renelle Richardson

1999 – Sylvia Gomes Durate

1998 – Lauren Bergamo

1997 – Merissa Starnes

1996 – Stacy Perrone

1995 – Amy Zappone

1994 – MaryGrace Santagata

1993 – Kimberly Burgess

1992 – Valorie Abate

1991 – Stephanie Stiefel

1990 – Bianca Salahashourian

1989 – Marlena Marshall

1988 – Marie Caporale

1987 – Michele Eaton

1986 – Lorraine Hudson

1985 – Lorine Guagenti

1984 – Joann Caruso

1983 – Dakeita Vanderburg

1982 – Kelly Slater

1981 – Virginia Reichardt

1980 – Jeanne Caruso

1979 – Laura Kaufmann

1978 – Maryalice Flineroy

1977 – Karen Kopins

1976 – Debra LaRoche

1975 – Mary Cadorette

1974 – Elisa Heinemann

1973 – Deborah Blanchard

1972 – Linda Kapral

1971 – Priscilla Doyle

1970 – Cynthia Fowler

1969 – Carol Jean Norval

1968 – Gunnell Ragone

1967 – Diane Bylo

1966 – Caroline Gelish

1965 – Donna Scott

1964 – Honora Bukowski

1963 – Valerie Stetson

1962 – Diane DeMaio

1961 – Karen Scalise

1960 – Wendy Mitchell

1959 – Diana Klug

1958 – Billie Turner

1957 – Suan Lightbown

1956 – Joy Corrado

1955 – Audrey Figlar

1954 – Dorothy Hopkins

1953 – Sally Middleton

1952 – Joyce Yeske

1951 – Beverly Buriant

1950 – Renee Roy

1949 – Barbara Smetana

1948 – Fairfax Mason

1947 – Louise Bienvenu

1946 – Joan Turner

1945 – Sylvia Shaw

1944 -Barbara Fisher

1943 – Mary Rice

1942 – Alice Clifford

1941 – Daphne Gladding

1940 – Dorothy Pickard

1939 – Frieda Lampar

1938 – Blanche Hawley

1937 – Frances Greene

1936 – Tilie Grey 

1935 – Margaretta Kling

1933 – Marian Bergeron

(Miss America 1933 & 1934)